The Law Office of Craig Bondy
Call For A Free Consultation
212-257-8321
Habla Español
Review Us

New York Court of Appeals allows unlimited license plate scanning

Drivers cannot reasonably expect any privacy in their license plate numbers, according to New York's highest court. After considering the question for the first time, the court held that law enforcement may use license plate scanners at will -- even when no one is suspected of any crime.

Police agencies across the state have been using the technology for years, although neither the courts nor the legislature had officially sanctioned its use. For example, according to the ACLU, police in Rhinebeck, population 7,548, scanned 164,043 license plates over the course of just three months in 2011. A total of eight were linked in any way to suspicious activity.

Despite finding the vast, vast majority of motorists hadn't done anything wrong, the results of those scans are stored in a long-term database. The legislature and courts have not specified how long such records can be kept, according to TheNewspaper.com, a journal focusing on driving issues.

It's unclear what legitimate law enforcement purpose is served by scanning the license plates of every possible driver, as police seem to have done in Rhinebeck. It wouldn't be necessary to scan a license plate to prove a traffic violation, so revenue from tickets wouldn't seem to be the issue.

However, license plate scanning could flag people with outstanding warrants. Why would a village like Rhinebeck want to look for people with warrants out on them? Arresting such individuals might allow the arresting agency to seize money and property from the driver. As long as the police can make a reasonable argument that the arrestee's assets were tied to criminal activity, they can seize that property and keep it until the arrestee files a case to get it back.

Doesn't New York's high court care about mass surveillance?

Legally, this case was not about mass surveillance, unfortunately. The court did not address whether police agencies could use license scanners to keep tabs on people.

The issue the court did address was whether scanning someone's license plate is legally considered a government search. Searches have traditionally been ruled to occur only in places where someone would have a reasonable expectation of privacy. In other words, your home, car and pockets may not be searched without a specific, good reason. On the other hand, reading your bumper stickers would not be considered a search at all.

Unreasonable searches and seizures violate our Fourth Amendment rights. As for license plate scans, "we hold that such a check, even without any suspicion of wrongdoing, is permissible, and does not constitute a search," the court wrote. Furthermore, if a warrant or other evidence of criminal activity is found, it can be used to justify pulling the driver over.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Call 212-257-8321 to receive a free, no-obligation ticket evaluation from The Law Office of Craig Bondy or reach us by email.

Contact Our team Today

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Craig Bondy Cares. He Wants To Win As Much As You Do.

The Law Office of Craig Bondy
225 Broadway, Room 850
New York, NY 10007

Phone: 212-257-8321
Fax: 212-274-9264
Map & Directions

Review Us
  • visa-image
  • master-image
  • am-express-image
  • discover-image
contact-map-image